Three ways to own it
Gold you wear, gold on your demat, gold in a fund
All three track the same metal. What changes is the cost of buying, the hassle of keeping it safe, and how easily you can sell a small part when you need to.
-
Physical gold
Jewellery, coins and bars. Jewellery carries making charges of roughly 8 to 25% that you rarely get back when you sell, plus GST on purchase. Coins and bars cost less to make but need a locker and a trusted buyer.
-
Gold ETF
A mutual fund unit listed on the stock exchange, each unit backed by high-purity physical gold held by the fund. You buy and sell during market hours through a demat and trading account, like a share.
-
Gold fund (fund of funds)
A regular mutual fund that puts your money into a gold ETF for you. No demat needed, SIP from ₹500 a month, and you redeem at the day's NAV. Costs are slightly higher than holding the ETF directly.
Side by side
Paper gold vs physical gold
The price of gold is the same for all three. The table shows where the difference in your final amount actually comes from.
| Point | Jewellery / coins | Gold ETF | Gold fund |
|---|---|---|---|
| Extra cost when buying | Making charges (jewellery) plus 3% GST | Brokerage, small yearly expense ratio | Yearly expense ratio, a little higher than ETF |
| Purity | Depends on the seller and hallmark | Backed by high-purity gold held by the fund | Same, through the ETF it holds |
| Storage | Home or bank locker, with its rent | Demat account | Account statement, no demat |
| Smallest amount | One coin, usually 1 gram or more | One unit, roughly the price of 1 gram or less | ₹500 SIP or ₹1,000 lump sum in many funds |
| Selling a small part | Hard, the buyer sets the deduction | Any market day, if there are buyers | Any business day at NAV |
| Monthly SIP | Not practical | Possible through some brokers | Yes, standard |
| Can you wear it | Yes | No | No |
Charges vary by seller and scheme; check the scheme document for the current expense ratio. Mutual fund investments are subject to market risks, read all scheme related documents carefully.
How much gold
A slice for balance, not a bet
Gold pays no interest and no dividend. Over long stretches it has broadly kept pace with inflation, and it often rises in the years when equity falls. That makes it useful as a shock absorber, and a poor engine for long-term growth.
So we treat it as a fixed share of your portfolio, rebalanced once a year. If gold has a great year and grows to 14% of your money, we trim it back. If it falls to 4%, the next SIPs top it up.
On a ₹10 lakh portfolio, for illustration
- Cautious investor
- 10% gold, about ₹1,00,000
- Balanced investor
- 8% gold, about ₹80,000
- Growth investor, long horizon
- 5% gold, about ₹50,000
- Jewellery you already own
- Count it separately, it is rarely sold
A starting point we discuss, not a rule. Your share depends on your goals, age and what else you hold.
SIP in gold
Buying a little every month
Gold prices swing too. A monthly SIP in a gold fund spreads your buying over good and bad months, so you are not guessing the right day.
Pick the amount
Work back from your target share. ₹10 lakh portfolio, 8% gold: about ₹80,000 over time, or ₹2,000 a month alongside your equity SIPs.
Choose fund or ETF
No demat or small monthly sums: gold fund. Already trade shares and want lower cost: gold ETF.
Review once a year
We check whether gold has drifted above or below its share and adjust the SIP, not the whole portfolio.
₹2,000 a month for 10 years
- You put in
- ₹2,40,000
- Assumed growth
- 8% a year
- Could grow to
- ₹3,68,331
8% is an assumed rate for illustration only. Gold has had flat and falling stretches lasting several years. Mutual fund investments are subject to market risks, read all scheme related documents carefully. Past performance may or may not be sustained in future.
Try your own numbers
Jewellery is not the same thing
Keep the wedding set. Plan the rest separately.
Family jewellery carries meaning, and most of it will never be sold. That is fine, but it means it should not be counted as the gold part of your investment plan.
- A ₹2 lakh necklace with 15% making charges holds about ₹1.7 lakh of gold on day one.
- Selling old jewellery usually means melting deductions and a price the jeweller decides.
- A gold fund lets you sell exactly ₹20,000 worth on a weekday, at a published NAV.
Honest view
What gold does, and what it does not
We would rather you hold a little gold for the right reason than a lot for the wrong one.
Does well
- Often holds or rises when equity markets fall sharply
- Rises when the rupee weakens, since gold is priced in dollars
- Easy to add through SIP, easy to trim at rebalancing
- No credit risk in the way a bond or deposit carries
Does not do
- Pay interest or dividends; all return comes from price
- Rise in a straight line; flat runs of 5 years or more have happened
- Replace equity for long goals like retirement
- Give regular income, so it is not a pension tool
Questions
Gold questions we hear often
Still unsure? Send us your question and we reply on WhatsApp.
Gold ETF or gold fund: which one should I pick?
If you already have a demat and trading account and invest larger sums, a gold ETF usually costs a little less each year. If you want a ₹500 to ₹5,000 monthly SIP without a demat, a gold fund is simpler. The gold underneath is the same.
Is now a good time to buy gold?
Nobody can call gold prices reliably, us included. That is why we suggest a fixed share and a monthly SIP rather than a big one-time purchase after a price jump.
Can I convert my gold fund units into coins later?
Generally no. You sell units and receive money in your bank account. If you want jewellery for a wedding, you can redeem and buy it then, which also avoids years of locker rent.
Should gold be part of my child's education plan?
A small share can steady a 10 to 15 year goal, but the growth part should come from equity funds. As the goal comes within three years, we shift money to debt funds, not gold.
Is a gold fund risky?
Gold prices can fall 15 to 20% in a year and stay low for a while. It is less volatile than small cap equity, but it is not a fixed deposit. Mutual fund investments are subject to market risks, read all scheme related documents carefully.
Talk to us
How much gold should you hold?
Tell us roughly what you have today. We reply on WhatsApp with a suggested gold share, fund or ETF, and a monthly SIP figure.
- No charge for the first conversation
- Categories explained, no pressure to switch
- Reviewed once a year with the rest of your funds
Related